The elephant remains in the room: Women leaders in the Caribbean and the silent political fight.

BY R.D.

Part I

Although the glass ceiling may have been shattered in the Caribbean and other impoverished and emerging countries, it still remains intact.

Despite having more tools, data, and even resources to tackle problems, it appears that with each election cycle, the stakes become higher.

Photo by Sharon McCutcheon

Political opponents will debate which candidate is most suited to tackle socioeconomic concerns including violence, poverty, inequality, and division—even those who have contributed to the discourse— to establish a brighter future.

It can be challenging for talented individuals to gain a place at the table. It isn’t because of what they know, but rather who they are.

Today, my opinion is a detached approach, reviewing a few female leaders in the region, and unveiling hidden potential in a few voting boxes.

Several women have risen to the challenge since the colonial era, thereby ushering in a new era of leadership. However, since the few women I have chosen to highlight, several things have changed.

They have successfully cracked a few glasses, but are they really busted in the region.

Shortly after a few successful women leaders lost re-election campaigns, many took advantage of the chance to blame them for their failures, rather than praising their accomplishments and adopting what experts saw as poor decisions on key matters.

They were excessively tough, held strong opinions, exhibited an attitude, and struggled to adapt to shifting demographics, thereby distancing themselves from the working class.

A list of notable women leaders from the Caribbean archives:

The Hon. Eugenia Charles: Prime minister of Dominica, July 21, 1980, – June 14, 1995,

The Hon. Portia Simpson-Miller: Prime minister of Jamaica; March 2006 – September 2007 and again January 2012 – March 2016

The Hon. Kamla Persad-Bissessar Prime Minister: Trinidad and Tobago, May 2010 – September 2015.

In recent decades, these women highlighted above have emerged from the shadows and pursued positions of greater responsibility. However, unfortunately, many of them have faced failure.

The lack of additional openings in the ceiling has made it difficult for a lot more stuff to get through.

Eugenia Charles holds the distinction of being the inaugural female prime minister of Dominica and represents the Caribbean’s first female lawyer.

Since the death on July 21, 1980, until June 14, 1995, Dominica has not experienced any further deaths.

All three candidates, Portia Simpson, Kamla Persad, and the late Eugenia Charles, lost their re-election bids. Instead of focusing on their political achievements, it led to more critical examinations of how they lost.

Several historical reports show that even as leaders of their respective countries, Portia Simpson-Miller and Kamla Persad were subjected to unreasonable and cruel treatment by the press.

Political experts report that women faced pressure to achieve more with limited resources, including from peers and dictating men in the legislative-parliamentary system.

Frequently, individuals’ gender takes precedence over their abilities or commitment to public service. But for this opinion, Instead of focusing on what should have been done, my main concern is determining the most ideal course of action for these nations going forward.

As a side note, other women have served as Prime Minister of the Netherlands Antilles, which include Aruba, Curacao, St. Maarten, and Bonaire, and are known as Dutch Caribbean colonies.

The hazy mirror continues to struggle with cleaning up the remnants of its past.

Leta Hong Fincher of CNN recently reported that a “United Nations and Inter-Parliamentary Union report highlighted that 10 of 152 elected heads of state were women, and men made up 75 percent of parliamentarians, 73 percent of managerial decision-makers, and 76 percent of people in mainstream news media.” Fincher said.

Women have significantly contributed to the advancement of these local political communities, thought men often dominate them, whether as educators, nurses, police officers, or wives who keep the family together.

Despite the fact that many great female leaders have emerged in various societies, there is still a significant gap between gender equality and political advancement.

There are many barriers that still exist in our society, and while I am not qualified to speak on women issues, but many have been documented and may continue to play a role today.

For example, I recently read about Lisa Hanna, a former World 1993 contestant and Jamaican Member of Parliament whose personal beauty overshadows her ideas.

Photo by Emre Can Acer

Sadly, it seems on some of these shores today, the selection of our modern-day female leaders resembles a “beauty pageant,” with their physical appearance taking precedence over their abilities or economic policies.

The room’s unspoken elephant:

According to political pundits, opposition leader Dr. Phillip was one of Jamaica’s finest legislators, and his experience benefited the country greatly.

However, because demographics have shifted to a younger voters, some likely voters may believe it is time to hand over power.

Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko

Can he or others, on the other hand, instantly remove the barriers that women frequently face in politics, barriers that have been woven by a decade of a stained mirror woven by an old colonial and slavery mentality that only a few people can overcome?

Most importantly, can he use his abilities and skills to capture the imagination of young voters and persuade them to change course or continue to steer this political ship into an iceberg?

To show, an elephant is present in political and leadership rooms worldwide, including Jamaica. Even though her political views may accord with the majority, her time to lead tend to be uncertain.

In the eyes of many Jamaicans, Lisa Hanna has a better chance of delivering a clear decision concerning the country’s future than any other candidate, regardless of party affiliation.

The question of whether the Honorable Dr. Phillips will hand over his power to her or another comrade after decades in office has sparked controversy.

Is she or any other comrade able to put pressure on the Honorable Dr. Phillips, leader of the People’s National Party (PNP) to yeald power?

When it comes to guard changes, it is important for the party to acknowledge that, eventually, the male emperor may have to give up some power.

Unfortunately, it appears that no one has the authority to persuade a less-than-enthusiastic male opposition leader to cede control.

Many locals thought that it would provide the nation the opportunity to mount a serious challenge against Prime Minister Holness.

Hon. Lisa Hanna: Member of Parliament-Jamaica

It would also serve as an inspiration for future generations of young women, encouraging them to participate in politics and pass legislation that safeguard and better their futures.

Will she succeed Dr. Peter Phillips’ as Leader of the Opposition remain an open question?

Unfortunately, I am not a political expert or a voter, but based on my observations, it appears that when the PNP ship sinks in the next election, the current leadership will also go down with it.

Part II

What is the next step in the search for the next woman leader?

There was minimal discussion of veiled sexism or misogynistic views. I mentioned before that I am not an expert on women’s upward mobility; they know what is best for them and where they can excel in society.

Call it like it is: It is crucial to acknowledge and not downplay the subtle or minimal discussions about hidden sexism and misogynistic viewpoints.

While it can be challenging to balance their respective responsibilities, it is equally important to have a group of next-level women players on the bench who are willing to step in and handle the political game.

Often by the time she assumes leadership, the outcome often undergoes significant changes.

Every election should unquestionably focus on the next generation, with rigorous debates that appropriately balance voters’ legitimate concerns and interests with their economic future.

The gradual rise of populism in the Caribbean, particularly today, has never been successful. It almost always results in obvious personal financial gains for many elected officials.

Unfortunately, Lisa’s experience has paralleled others in modern politics—difficulties, setbacks, a few wins, and more barriers. The glass ceiling remains mainly intact, despite a few cracks.

It also provides in-depth understanding of the root causes of not enough of women in leadership roles, both locally and internationally.

A delicate balancing act

Again I’m not an expert on women’s politics, but despite the fact that more women are running for office in the region, it appears that the men in charge, are still in charge.

A sizable contingent of supporters or women at the table does not always result in legislative victories.

Economic policy-making in the region sometimes resembles learning the ropes at a local mechanic’s shop. Only when a supervisor has no choice or can no longer lead, then they spread the opportunity to show off the staff skills.

Clinging to power, on the other hand, breeds division, disconnect, and a stalemate of new ideas for advancement in paving the way for the next generation of female leaders.

In order to bridge the gap between the wealthy and the poor, it is crucial to develop a comprehensive strategy that addresses women issues, safety, abuse, criminal activity, like attracting new investments, to promotes economic growth.

This is particularly important given the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, stagnant economic conditions, and high levels of unemployment.

Of course, some will push back to appear to be conscious of these issues, and even a day at church before an election, which I understand; they’re all politicians, and I’m not in the room, but after the sermons on change, it appears to be the same scriptures.

If the regional legislative system requires future female leaders to win the approval of men in order to ascend to the top, this is problematic.

Will the elephants leave the room so that other well-qualified female leaders can become the party’s commander in order to be elected as the next Prime Minister?

The revolving door of leadership:

Considering the current political climate, this assessment is not excessively severe. Many political leaders utilize appointed positions as a means to showcase their commitment to diversity. However, once elected, they tend to govern in a manner reminiscent of the old boys’ system.

Being a good leader is all about maintaining a stable environment and understanding that, as a passenger, you may benefit from your years of road experience rather than trying to drive while distracted by personal requirements.

Every election cycle appears to have the same guards and a similar platform for economic prosperity on many fronts, jobs, education, and access to good and affordable healthcare regardless of party affiliation, particularly in poor and developing countries plagued by crime and economic stagnation?

Perhaps term limits should be considered, and communities throughout the region should ask themselves: do they feel safer, better off, regardless of party affiliation?

Photo by Stephen Rupp

Every vote has consequences, but losing an election does not mean that women’s advancement in the Caribbean or elswhere is over.

More women in politics are needed, especially for adolescent girls who need a role model, better education, job opportunities, healthcare, and security.

These communities must begin to prioritize what is best for their country over short-term personal benefit.

Many people believe in “democracy,” yet in an oligarchy system in which leaders choose who they believe their society will recognize based on an emotional connection, but are completely disconnected from the reality of the community’s needs.

This allows the elected leaders to gain more control over their personal power while pretending to be working for the community at all times.

Often, operatives are purposefully used even at the highest levels; many at the table will hear her voice, but if it is solely for campaigning to keep power for personal socioeconomic standing, she must reconsider her job or impact in building the next generation.

Photo by Mikhail Nilov

It’s no different from sending Mother’s Day tweets to your constituents, which is a nice gesture but lacks a comprehensive economic strategy aimed at lifting these young women out of poverty, as well as protection, victim rights, and resources to stay safe and care for their families.

Giving out a few shopping bags to the impoverished is always a good thing, but when it comes with a camera and a 30-second film to tweet, it’s approaching exploitation.

While this is helpful for increasing voter turnout and preparing for the next election cycle,  long-term economic mobility is still a key factor in the divided neighborhoods.

Taking a stand in the face of reality.

PART III

To be more than a statistic, more women must unite around similar threads, regardless of political allegiance, to show that politics and action can be the difference between success and failure for students.

Photo by PICHA Stock

Because many of the women in the region’s official titles are “former,” this is not the time to embark on an apology tour, because it cannot become a safe haven.

It’s been proven in numerous studies that men are notoriously bad at apologizing for their mistakes.

To overcome these barriers, lmore eaders must coach and encourage the next generation to lead. Young people in the region must believe that they have the potential to become the region’s leaders.

Approximately half of women in the workforce today have an undergraduate degree, matching the number of men with a college education according to Pew’s analysis and academic research.

Sadly, despite these academic achievements, there are still barriers to developing leaders and business owners who can serve as role models for the next generation of leaders and owners.

These leaders must view the obstacles or chronic challenges that women confront as an integral part of them, rather than as women working in distinct areas of the house to change the hurdles, especially in impoverished communities.

The next generation of leaders in the region must know that there is still hope for them.

This is not a last-ditch appeal for males to resign from positions of authority. And just because you cannot see the elephant in the room, it does not imply he is not present.

Given the complexity of the global economy, a candidate’s intellectual and physical capacity to lead a country in distress is a fair issue; yet, given the current situation, I believe she must have a fair shot if she is equipped.

It can be done, and nearby is a ray of light.

Prime Minister Mottley is widely recognized as one of the region’s most brilliant independent thinkers, having previously been elected as the political opposition’s leader prior to his unexpected triumph in 2018.

She recently pushed for stronger moral leadership and critical collaboration to enhance health systems across the area, particularly in light of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Hon. Mia Amor Mottley: Prime Minister of Barbados

Her charismatic leadership and understanding of what it takes to lead in the twenty-first century make her a refreshing addition to the region.

Reports say she put the interests of her country ahead of personal gain, mismanagement, and corruption.

Hope does exist, but its realization will require more than just Prime Minister Mottley’s efforts. As noted, to ensure the development of the next generation of players, it is crucial for the team to have a group of reserves readily available, rather than waiting until the season is over to rebuild.

Furthermore, there are other women all over the world who are inspiring others, breaking down barriers, and forging their own paths, particularly in poor and developing countries.

The number of people occupying higher office chairs has been increasing for decades, even though there are fewer people in these areas, especially in coastal regions and other impoverished,and developing nations, but the sun is on the horizon.

While not all women share the same approaches, political methods, experience-based values, religious, culture or other views, the drive for socioeconomic equality, upward mobility, and gender equity remains, as various scientists have underlined.

I don’t have a ballot and I’m not voting for anyone. A female candidate should not lose an election just because she is female or because she is competing against a male candidate; similarly, a male candidate should not lose an election simply because he is running against a female candidate.

Today, I only wanted to highlight a few what i I believe are generally underestimated in terms of what they’ve accomplished, the challenges they’ve faced, and the work that still needs to be done to attain that balance.

This Women’s History Month, let’s honor Portia Simpson-Miller, former PM of Jamaica`

By R.D. Miller

A Brief History: When we commemorate Women’s History Month, it serves as a reminder of the significant progress women have made over the years.

For instance, in 1893, New Zealand became the first nation to grant women the right to vote, and more recently in 2015, Saudi Arabia followed suit.

Challenges persist in our current society, with issues such as socio-economic inequality, gender equity, and racial and cultural divisions.

The Politics:

Despite differences in opinion, the Honorable Portia Simpson-Miller has made significant contributions to the advancement of women in the Jamaican government and the Caribbean region

In addition, her historical achievement cannot be reduced to a mere electoral defeat. She provided young girls and women with an opportunity to envision a future filled with possibilities, encouraging them to overcome obstacles regardless of their political affiliations.

Although many of us may not possess the necessary expertise to discuss women’s issues, we are fortunate to reside in a time when leadership is diverse and inclusive, regardless of gender.

However, it is important to acknowledge the challenges that lie ahead in achieving equal opportunities for women.

The Hon. Prime Minister-Jamaica Portia Simpson-Miller 3-2005–2007 and 1-2012-3-2016

Occasionally, it is necessary to pause and reflect, without any prompting, on the challenges at hand.

By carefully examining the errors and acknowledging the achievements of those who have triumphed over adversity, we contribute to the advancement of our society.

The complexity of what is not being said

The nation recognized the significant ascent of the former Prime Minister, while the opposition party capitalized on the discontent among young people who had a broad agenda that resonated with the majority of the electorate.

They expressed a desire for increased responsibility and a clearer plan for their future, as the time had come to transition from two decades of her party’s leadership.

Whether they will experience improvement in the period leading up to the next electoral cycle is a matter that only history can determine.

The 2016 election took on a significant role beyond initial expectations, with ample blame being assigned, as is customary in any election.

There are those who have contended that the party failed to acknowledge the socioeconomic divide and the trajectory of the nation, necessitating a greater sense of accountability and openness.

Some observers pointed out the internal challenges she faced, and how she made the decision to step down from seeking re-election in order to maintain her position as the first female Prime Minister of Jamaica and leader of the National People’s Party.

Many locals argued that they do not know for sure what was given up, but it was a generational shift, led by a new leader who used technology, and promises to galvanize the younger voters.

The once local street politics- door-to door moved to social media, and that generation was much older and more difficult to reach, but it does not take away from the centrality of women in the region future.

Unfortunately, when women are in positions of power, it seems pundits often raise more questions about their leadership abilities and downplay their potential for collaboration, instead focusing solely on their acquisition of power.

While democracy flourishes with a diversity of opposing perspectives. Nevertheless, when political discourse takes a vitriolic, abusive, and hateful turn, it only serves to reinforce the difficulties and obstacles surrounding their vision, as well as the harsh reality of misogynistic views that further erect barriers.

The bloggers and pundits were quick to react on social media. She displayed a lack of assertiveness, high expectations, and a loss of concentration, as well as a disconnection from the community and other related matters.

However, few discussions revolved around the impact of political parties on women’s candidacy. They face stereotypes that hinder their progress, which adds to the ongoing struggle for gender equality.

Of course, there were individuals who found themselves frustrated with their economic circumstances, rising crime rates, and the limited prospects for recent university graduates burdened with substantial student loans.

They also had to contend with high inflation, unemployment, and a growing divide between the privileged and the less fortunate.

Portia was well acquainted with the absurdity and fervor of the media. In 2004, newspapers highlighted a situation involving Christopher Charles, who questioned her actions as a member of Parliament.

They raised concerns about her decision to abstain on a resolution that criticized the insufficient funding for local fire services. Perhaps this inquiry has never been posed regarding an individual.

Her time in power has brought attention to the significant challenges faced by women in these arenas, such as the struggle for equal representation, collective goals, effective leadership, fundamental rights, and overall security.

However, from her loss emerged a fresh start that made a lasting impact, illuminating a path for the next generation of female leaders in the region.

The scorecard

Over time, as is the case for many individuals who have experienced a setback in an election, it can take a while for the policies that have been implemented to gain traction.

The future leader will come to appreciate the advantages. Similarly, they have the ability to overturn policies that do not align with their political philosophy.

It is often argued that when the economy declines or crime rates rise, past leaders are often held responsible, while current leaders are quick to claim credit for positive outcomes.

This tribute does not focus on the nation’s growing social inequality or the positive outcomes in various areas, nor does it assign responsibility to any particular party, as there is ample blame to be shared.

Historians specializing in economic policy in the region will have access to comprehensive data on various aspects such as GDP, debt ratio, wages, investments, healthcare spending, education, crime, infrastructure, construction, imports, and exports throughout her tenure in office.

The administration portrayed a vehicle ascending a challenging incline, encountering minimal obstacles and rough patches along the way, as it progresses towards a more seamless path until the next driver assumes control.

The bumpy journey was the result of long-standing shortcomings on the part of both parties to develop a holistic approach to address the complex issue of crime, poverty, and the declining middle class.

Appreciating the former prime minister’s success involves a nuanced understanding of the complex political landscape during that election cycle.

It is not merely a matter of revisiting or rationalizing the provocative nature of their campaign, nor is it about dismissing the concerns of new voters or the perception of a one-sided economic policy favoring the wealthy and foreign investors.

This essay highlights the significant impact of women’s leadership and their valuable contributions to the region. It encourages readers to consider the potential for progress, irrespective of political affiliations.

Every election has consequences

Her defeat once again highlighted the ongoing challenges faced by women in various domains. Whether it is a woman running for office, or working in a male-dominated environment.

They often encounter significant obstacles when advocating for important issues such as inclusion, shared priorities, women’s rights, gay rights, security, and environmental protection. Unfortunately, these efforts are frequently met with strong resistance.

Even in the present day, there continues to be a significant lack of female representation in global parliaments, with studies consistently indicating that women make up only around 20% of these governing bodies.

This under representation is even more pronounced in ministerial positions. And I don’t need to extensively analyze or review feminist literature as a man to recognize that decision-making by multiple women is often a challenging task that is met with more resistance compared to their male colleagues.

In reality, it will be the responsibility of the region’s historians and scholars to address and resolve these inquiries.

Did her leadership differ from the other leaders?
Does her policy represent women’s interests?
Are there still echos of the same concerns today?

The pursuit of equality is not a matter of chance, as some individuals in the media may mistakenly think. Success is often determined by the level of preparation, hard work, and dedication that one puts in, regardless of whether they are promoted or not.

Portia Simpson-Miller and other remarkable women who have significantly contributed to the betterment of our world should not be solely evaluated based on a limited set of economic measurements.

Of course, it is essential to have a deep understanding of geopolitical, social, and economic issues and their connection to everyday situations, such as a corner shop operating without electricity or running water.

Collaboration is crucial in addressing the pressing issues of high unemployment, corruption, and crime. It is important to prioritize spending, with a focus on investing in education, healthcare, and environmental protection.

However, it is also essential to be mindful of the unique circumstances and needs of each local community.

The cultural stigma that lingers:

Unfortunately, the political arrogance that arose from colonialism has caused certain individuals to believe that a leader must have graduated from a prestigious university, obtained a law degree, or pursued a Ph.D.

This mindset has resulted in the perpetuation of outdated laws in government and the reinforcement of a class system. Nevertheless, her success demonstrates that even those with fewer advantages can rise to positions of leadership, starting from modest origins.

Her active involvement at the highest level will inspire others to exercise their legislative power for the betterment of the country.

It is crucial for individuals to have the freedom to think independently rather than simply conforming to group dynamics.

Only then can we effectively tackle systemic issues. Despite her shortcomings in political leadership, her unwavering determination and other achievements remain noteworthy.

She discovered a harmonious equilibrium between optimism and oppression and has consistently proclaimed, “indeed, she was capable,” preceding even the pronouncement of U.S. President Obama, “Indeed, we are capable.”

She has dedicated herself to the public for decades and has demonstrated that when women are empowered and actively involved in decision-making, they contribute to the creation of a more prosperous society.

The Region’s Prime Ministers club to-date.

Eugenia Charles, 1980 – 1995 Dominica

Kamla Persad-Bissessar, 2010 – 2015 Trinidad and Tobago

Women’s Coalition Continues to Play a Vital Role in Shattering the Glass Ceiling:

Research has demonstrated that when women collaborate and address factors that foster strong connections among them, society reaps the rewards.

I do not possess the ability to vote, nor do I align myself with any particular political party or hold any personal inclinations regarding who should govern the nation. The key to uplifting this aspect of our heritage lies in the pursuit of effective governance..

Regardless of the obstacles, limitations, political considerations, and even differences of opinion, it is important to acknowledge and celebrate every Women’s Month, including her birthday.

The accomplishments cannot be reduced to a single election, but rather leave a lasting impact for young women to aspire and achieve their goals.

Thank you: The Esteemed Simpson-Miller was a trailblazer, even though she may have missed out on some recognition, she motivated generations to assume greater leadership positions in government.

Even the knowledge gained from these lessons was crucial for gaining a deeper understanding of the forthcoming obstacles.

When you take a step back and offer guidance to the younger generation, they will gain a deeper understanding.

Regardless of political differences and personal opinions, the significance of public diplomacy cannot be overlooked.

I had the opportunity to witness this firsthand, and it was truly fascinating to observe and listen, even though I was relatively young and on duty at the time.

May I say, today, you appear quite impressive at the age of 70, and it would be beneficial for the island of Jamaica to have your continued presence in order to offer further oversight and vocalize your thoughts, now that you have the opportunity for introspection.

Condoleezza Rice, the 66th Secretary of State of the United States, and Honorable Portia Simpson-Miller dancing. Reggae .

At the end of the day, poverty and inequality remain a rough wave on the shores for the downtrodden, so regardless of politics, hits and mistakes, we have to stand back and honor her dedication to public service. Let’s hope who comes next will succeed.